Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Quiggin's avatar

Great, but I feel you've buried the lead a bit. The issue isn't wanting a garden if you can pay for it, it's demanding that all your neighbours have gardens too (the analogy with racially-based convenants is pretty obvious). You get to that point, but too far down.

Expand full comment
AC's avatar

Isn’t the correct NIMBY counter that this isn’t actually racist, it’s really just classist, and any racist outcome is due to the uneven allocation of wealth across racial groups (kind of a systemic racism definition).

Basically, the people in Beverly Hills just want to be around other astoundingly rich people and if that means it’s mostly whites (because whites tend to be more astoundingly rich) nothing much they can do about that.

Btw, this isn’t a good (or morally right) argument. But it does attempt to move away from the charge of racism specifically.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts